Trending Now

How Our Top-5 Articles of 2021 Foretell What’s Coming in 2022

How Our Top-5 Articles of 2021 Foretell What’s Coming in 2022

Litigation Finance has enjoyed another year of growth and innovation, as we enter a shocking third year of the COVID pandemic. New funds have arisen, affording more potential claimants an opportunity to experience their day in court. New entrants are emerging in the funding space, innovative investment opportunities are popping up in the form of ILOs on the blockchain, and prominent examples of the benefits of legal funding are arising with increasing frequency. Each of our top-5 most popular articles in the last year illustrate an industry trend we think is worth keeping an eye on. These trends also offer clues as to what we can expect in the coming year. Below are the top-5 articles from 2021:  #5) Litigation Finance and Patent Litigation—Fast Friends 2021 Trend: One thing we’ve learned about third-party litigation funding is that once clients and plaintiffs get a taste of it, they recommend it highly. This leads to explosive growth in specific sectors. In this contributed post, Slingshot Capital founder Ed Truant explains that in 2021, Patent and IP litigation went from a relatively uncommon investment to one that is highly sought out. Some of this can be attributed to the pandemic and the investor rush toward uncorrelated assets. But some of the popularity of IP litigation investment stems from the possibility of awards in the multi-millions. As funders sharpen their due diligence skills and use new tech to predict case outcomes, the likelihood of sourcing meritorious patent cases grows. From the article: “It used to be the case that patent litigation was viewed negatively by the litigation funding community…Then about two years ago, I noticed an increase in the number of patent cases being brought to the attention of funders, and in the number of funders marketing that they are interested in providing financing to patent cases.” What does this mean for 2022? If/when COVID restrictions are lifted and life slowly returns to normal, we’ll likely see similar growth in other sectors. We know that when law firms and clients have a good experience with funders, word gets around. The expectation is that Litigation Finance will improve in recognition and accessibility. As a largely self-regulating industry, third-party legal funding continues to position itself as a public good. We have every reason to believe that will continue in 2022 #4) Litigation Finance Basics 2021 Trend: The popularity of this article, originally published in 2017, reveals interesting things about the business of legal funding. Legal professionals and many types of investors are taking an increased interest in litigation funding. It also underscores that this widespread curiosity about the industry is leading people to investigate it from its humble beginnings to its current role as a public good. From the article: “We don’t all have the same access to the legal system. Those with money have more access than those without. Litigation finance allows claimants without money to have the kind of access to justice that those with money currently enjoy. Obviously, that threatens some, but for the rest of us, litigation finance should be celebrated as a means of achieving equality of opportunity when it comes to preserving our legal rights.” What does this mean for 2022? We predict more of the same, probably on an even grander scale. As regulations become more welcoming to funders, investors are taking greater notice of the practice. Now that regulations are relaxing around non-lawyer ownership of legal firms, the potential for lawyer/funder co-ownership of firms has earned the interest of many prominent investment firms. Jurisdictions around the world are relaxing champerty and maintenance restrictions and creating an environment more welcoming to third-party funding for an array of legal matters. This includes arbitration, patent and IP litigation, and claims enforcement. The popularity of a back-to-basics piece like this one, demonstrates that more people in more industries are curious about what litigation funding can do for them. #3) The Impressive Growth of Commercial Litigation Finance 2021 Trend: Our third entry is another Ed Truant piece illustrating an interest in Litigation Finance from people outside the legal field. In this piece, however, emphasis is placed on the addressable market for litigation funding. This tells us that financial experts are looking toward third-party funding as a future investment. From the article: “I think it is important for all stakeholders to understand the size of an industry, so investors can determine whether it has the scale and growth attributes necessary to justify a long-term approach to investing in the sector.” What does this mean for 2022? We predict that hedge funds and private equity firms will continue to flock to the litigation funding sector. This may happen at an even faster clip, as certain types of litigation rise to prominence in the coming year. Breach of contract, insurance litigation, and issues of employer responsibility as related to COVID precautions are expected to flood court dockets in 2022. This amid an effort to catch up on the backlog of cases caused by court delays and closures.  More litigation means more opportunity for investors to avail themselves of the benefits of TPLF as an uncorrelated asset. #2) Investor Caveats in the Commercial LitFin Asset Class 2021 Trend: As an increasing number of investors seek out litigation funding, the pitfalls associated with this type of investment aren’t as well known. Ed Truant of Slingshot Capital, shows up again on our list, as he explains how investors can better understand this asset class. Matters of tail risk, gross vs net returns, portfolio valuation, and deployment risks are all areas investors will want to be familiar with. After all, just because an asset is uncorrelated, does not mean it is free from risk. From the article: “The asset class presents a unique opportunity to add an asset that has true non-correlation, along with inherent ESG attributes. This makes litigation finance a very attractive asset class. However, an investor needs to do their homework prior to executing an investment.”  What does this mean for 2022? The emphasis on ESG investing bodes well for the future. Litigation Finance’s commitment to investing in environmental, social justice, and governance litigation shines a light on the fact that LitFin investments can be simultaneously lucrative, and a net gain for society. #1) Bank Cartel Claims Europe Announces $12 Million Funding Round 2021 Trend: The popularity of this article is an affirmation of the growth and expansion of Litigation Finance in the EU market. The piece details three antitrust cases in which the fund will deploy cash. The banks are accused of engaging in cartel behavior—one of the most serious types of antitrust charges. This type of piece serves to illustrate how litigation funding helps fight corruption and works toward the public good. It also shows us that fundraising capital is out there for experienced funders with proven track records. From the article: “In these three cases, for example, the pension and hedge funds that lost millions of dollars…can effectively claim their damages through actions before a national court. …in most cases, the remaining question to be decided is the amount of damages. This makes antitrust litigation very attractive for investors.” What does this mean for 2022? We think this means even greater global expansion for Litigation Finance. While funding still has its naysayers, the global mood toward third-party legal funding is largely positive. As the practice casts a progressively wider net—most of those who have used litigation funding to pursue their litigation report being satisfied with the results. Legal funding is already growing in India, Singapore, Germany, South Africa, and China. There’s no reason to think expansion of the industry will not continue in 2022.

Commercial

View All

Federal Judge Says Funded Patent Cases “Won’t Die”

A federal judge in California has criticized the influence of third-party capital on patent litigation, telling a university audience that funded cases resist settlement because the money behind them is chasing a return target rather than the value of the claim.

As reported by Bloomberg Law, Judge Beth Labson Freeman of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California said at a Stanford Law School intellectual property forum that there is "lots of funny money out there" financing patent suits, and that "these cases won't die" regardless of their merits because funders prioritize financial targets.

Judge Freeman described the dynamic in terms of how it plays out in settlement discussions. "The plaintiff won't listen to what the value of the case is because we're not at their X number yet, and yet the case has less value," she said.

The remarks land in one of the most consequential venues for patent disputes in the country. The Northern District of California handles a substantial share of U.S. technology litigation, and judicial impatience there with funded claims carries weight beyond the courtroom in which it is voiced.

The comments also go to a criticism funders have faced for years: that outside capital changes the economics of settlement by giving a plaintiff a floor it cannot drop below. Funders have generally rejected the characterization, arguing that capital allows meritorious claims to be pursued to a proper valuation rather than abandoned cheaply under cost pressure. The argument is now being made from the bench.

Litigation Funders Move Into Social Media Addiction MDL

Litigation funders are taking positions in the mass tort litigation accusing Meta, TikTok and YouTube of designing their platforms to be addictive to adolescents, with one funder's involvement now visible on the court's docket.

As reported by Bloomberg Law, Houston-based Armadillo Litigation Funding has been named as an interested party in five cases within the Social Media Adolescent Addiction multi-district litigation pending in the Northern District of California. The funder is backing The Law Office of Paul Mankin, one of the plaintiffs' firms bringing claims in the proceeding.

The underlying suits allege that the sites were designed to be addictive, and attribute personal injuries including depression, anxiety, eating disorders and self-harm to their use. Defendants named in the litigation include Meta Platforms Inc., TikTok Inc. and Google's YouTube.

The MDL has the features that typically draw third-party capital: a large inventory of individual claims, well-resourced corporate defendants, and a plaintiffs' bar that must carry cases through years of pretrial proceedings before any recovery. Consumer-facing mass torts of this kind are capital-intensive long before they are resolved, which is precisely the gap funders are structured to fill.

What distinguishes this instance is visibility. Funder participation in mass tort litigation is widely assumed but rarely documented on the public record, and an interested-party designation places a funder's name in the docket at a time when the disclosure of third-party funding arrangements in federal multi-district litigation remains an active point of contention.

UK Justice Committee Backs PACCAR Reversal and Statutory Funding Regime

A cross-party committee of MPs has endorsed a package of civil justice reforms that would place third-party litigation funding under a statutory regulatory framework and reverse the Supreme Court's PACCAR decision with retrospective effect.

As reported by Legal Futures, the House of Commons Justice Select Committee, chaired by Labour MP Catherine Atkinson, published the findings of its access to justice inquiry this week. The headline recommendation is an NHS 111-style "national legal service" that would signpost and triage members of the public toward appropriate legal help. Alongside it, the committee backed the Civil Justice Council's recommendations on litigation funding.

Those recommendations include legislation to reverse PACCAR with retrospective effect, a proportionate statutory regulatory regime for third-party litigation funding, and allowing the Financial Conduct Authority to regulate portfolio funding arrangements as a form of lending. The committee also addressed the economic viability of conditional fee agreements and the rules governing costs and recoverability.

The report further called for work to improve the visibility and availability of before-the-event legal expenses insurance, and floated funding the proposed national legal service partly through undistributed collective action sums and what it described as carefully targeted contributions from litigation funding profits and high-value litigation.

For funders operating in England and Wales, the committee's endorsement adds parliamentary weight to the Civil Justice Council's position and signals that the retrospective reversal of PACCAR, long sought by the industry, now has support beyond the review process itself. The government has not yet responded to the recommendations.