Trending Now

GAO Releases Study of Litigation Finance Market

GAO Releases Study of Litigation Finance Market

Litigation funding has reached a level of maturity where it is now viewed as a common feature of many jurisdictions’ legal systems, rather than a rare occurrence, leading to wider conversations about how its use should be regulated by national governments. Whilst criticism of the practice exists from politicians and third-party pressure groups in the U.S., it is important to note the role of government agencies in shaping the future of regulation, including the Government Accountability Office (GAO). At the end of last year, the GAO released its study into the characteristics and trends of third-party litigation funding, aiming to provide an overarching picture of the current state of the market and the connected policy implications. The GAO stated that the purpose of this study was to fill the gap in public data about the industry, and to examine the issues raised by critics of litigation finance, such as questions around transparency and disclosure. The GAO’s study, which included an analysis of previously collected data by funders, reports by outside parties, and direct interviews with those involved in the industry, looked at all aspects of litigation finance between 2017 and 2021. The report included an examination of the advantages and disadvantages of third-party funding of litigation, as well as existing gaps in the markets and potential policy solutions and regulatory options. The GAO report is already receiving praise from industry participants. “The GAO report illustrates that proper regulation of the industry is welcome. The Alliance for Responsible Consumer Legal Funding (ARC) and its member companies welcome appropriate regulation,” said Eric Schuller, President of ARC, who added that “ARC members follow a set of best practices that are the industry standard.” The full report can be found here.

Commercial

View All

Federal Judge Says Funded Patent Cases “Won’t Die”

A federal judge in California has criticized the influence of third-party capital on patent litigation, telling a university audience that funded cases resist settlement because the money behind them is chasing a return target rather than the value of the claim.

As reported by Bloomberg Law, Judge Beth Labson Freeman of the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California said at a Stanford Law School intellectual property forum that there is "lots of funny money out there" financing patent suits, and that "these cases won't die" regardless of their merits because funders prioritize financial targets.

Judge Freeman described the dynamic in terms of how it plays out in settlement discussions. "The plaintiff won't listen to what the value of the case is because we're not at their X number yet, and yet the case has less value," she said.

The remarks land in one of the most consequential venues for patent disputes in the country. The Northern District of California handles a substantial share of U.S. technology litigation, and judicial impatience there with funded claims carries weight beyond the courtroom in which it is voiced.

The comments also go to a criticism funders have faced for years: that outside capital changes the economics of settlement by giving a plaintiff a floor it cannot drop below. Funders have generally rejected the characterization, arguing that capital allows meritorious claims to be pursued to a proper valuation rather than abandoned cheaply under cost pressure. The argument is now being made from the bench.

Litigation Funders Move Into Social Media Addiction MDL

Litigation funders are taking positions in the mass tort litigation accusing Meta, TikTok and YouTube of designing their platforms to be addictive to adolescents, with one funder's involvement now visible on the court's docket.

As reported by Bloomberg Law, Houston-based Armadillo Litigation Funding has been named as an interested party in five cases within the Social Media Adolescent Addiction multi-district litigation pending in the Northern District of California. The funder is backing The Law Office of Paul Mankin, one of the plaintiffs' firms bringing claims in the proceeding.

The underlying suits allege that the sites were designed to be addictive, and attribute personal injuries including depression, anxiety, eating disorders and self-harm to their use. Defendants named in the litigation include Meta Platforms Inc., TikTok Inc. and Google's YouTube.

The MDL has the features that typically draw third-party capital: a large inventory of individual claims, well-resourced corporate defendants, and a plaintiffs' bar that must carry cases through years of pretrial proceedings before any recovery. Consumer-facing mass torts of this kind are capital-intensive long before they are resolved, which is precisely the gap funders are structured to fill.

What distinguishes this instance is visibility. Funder participation in mass tort litigation is widely assumed but rarely documented on the public record, and an interested-party designation places a funder's name in the docket at a time when the disclosure of third-party funding arrangements in federal multi-district litigation remains an active point of contention.

UK Justice Committee Backs PACCAR Reversal and Statutory Funding Regime

A cross-party committee of MPs has endorsed a package of civil justice reforms that would place third-party litigation funding under a statutory regulatory framework and reverse the Supreme Court's PACCAR decision with retrospective effect.

As reported by Legal Futures, the House of Commons Justice Select Committee, chaired by Labour MP Catherine Atkinson, published the findings of its access to justice inquiry this week. The headline recommendation is an NHS 111-style "national legal service" that would signpost and triage members of the public toward appropriate legal help. Alongside it, the committee backed the Civil Justice Council's recommendations on litigation funding.

Those recommendations include legislation to reverse PACCAR with retrospective effect, a proportionate statutory regulatory regime for third-party litigation funding, and allowing the Financial Conduct Authority to regulate portfolio funding arrangements as a form of lending. The committee also addressed the economic viability of conditional fee agreements and the rules governing costs and recoverability.

The report further called for work to improve the visibility and availability of before-the-event legal expenses insurance, and floated funding the proposed national legal service partly through undistributed collective action sums and what it described as carefully targeted contributions from litigation funding profits and high-value litigation.

For funders operating in England and Wales, the committee's endorsement adds parliamentary weight to the Civil Justice Council's position and signals that the retrospective reversal of PACCAR, long sought by the industry, now has support beyond the review process itself. The government has not yet responded to the recommendations.