Trending Now

Mythbusting the Call for New Regulation of TPLF

By John Freund |

Mythbusting the Call for New Regulation of TPLF

The following is a contributed piece from Rupert Cunningham, Director for Growth and Membership Engagement at the International Legal Finance Association (ILFA).

In their call for more EU regulation last week, AmCham EU, Business Europe and their co-signatories make misleading and inaccurate allegations about third-party litigation funding. These calls have been repeated by the same groups over and over again, pushed by big corporations that simply do not want those harmed by their wrongful behaviour to have recourse in the judicial system. ILFA will continue to counter these claims in the strongest terms. Below we unravel some of the most common misleading statements:

Myth: “Third-party litigation funders currently operate in a regulatory vacuum and without any transparency requirements.”

There is no regulatory vacuum. Litigation funders are regulated under company law in the same way as any other business, for example, the Directive on unfair business-to-consumer commercial practices and the Directive on unfair terms in consumer contracts. Specific to litigation funding, activities are regulated by the Representative Actions Directive and the Collective Redress Directive.

Publicly traded funders are further regulated through legislation on securities and financial instruments and by the relevant stock exchanges and financial authorities. This includes publishing annual reports on financial performance. Examples of other EU rules that apply to listed funders include the Shareholder Rights Directive, Prospectus Regulation, MIFID II.

Lawyers engaged in litigation are bound by professional, regulatory, and fiduciary responsibilities to represent the best interests of their clients where they practise.

Myth: “A civil justice climate that is abundant in abusive claims and mass private third-party funded litigation, creates a chilling effect that deters businesses from innovating, investing, competing, and prospering.”

Supporting meritorious litigation does not deter businesses from innovating and prospering – it deters corporate wrongdoing. As long as companies behave responsibly and comply with the obligations set out in the law, they have nothing to fear from litigation funding.

Myth: “If civil litigation remains funded by unregulated private third parties, we expect a surge in speculative litigation in the EU, which would undermine public confidence in the European justice systems at a time when maintaining faith in our democratic institutions is so critical.”

Far from undermining public confidence in the legal system, a recent independent report from the European Law Institute (ELI) concluded litigation funding plays a ‘functionally vital role in facilitating access to justice in many jurisdictions’.[1]

With public funding (legal aid) increasingly concentrated in the criminal justice sphere, litigation funding offers vital assistance to claimants bringing meritorious civil claims to courts. Greater access to justice, supported by litigation funding, leads to the development of better legal jurisprudence – a benefit to our legal system and to the rule of the law.

Myth: “TPLF is a for-profit business model that allows private financiers, investment firms, and hedge funds, to sign confidential deals with lawyers or qualified entities to invest in lawsuits or arbitration in exchange for a significant portion of any compensation that may be awarded, sometimes as much as 40% of the total compensation but can go even substantially higher.”

Litigation funder’s fees reflect the level of risk undertaken (which will vary) and are assessed case-by-case.

Many funded cases are “David vs. Goliath” in nature with well-resourced defendants. This requires substantial upfront financial investment to level the playing field and for cases to proceed. In the UK sub-postmasters’ recent successful claim against the Post Office, the Post Office spent nearly 250m GBP on its defence.

Myth: “The financial incentives of such practices encourage frivolous and predatory litigation, but they also shortchange genuine claimants and consumers.”

Litigation funding is provided on a non-recourse basis, i.e. if the case is unsuccessful, the funder loses their entire investment. There is no logical financial incentive for litigation funders to fund frivolous legal claims. Funders’ due-diligence checks assist the justice system by weeding out unmeritorious claims that have a poor chance of success when put before a court. The approval rate for funding opportunities is as low as 3-5%.

Myth: “The introduction of a purely profit-motivated third party, often non-EU based, into the traditional lawyer-client relationship, raises serious ethical concerns and presents an economic security threat for Europe.”

The letter presents no substantive evidence that litigation funding is being used by ‘non-EU’ entities to destabilise the European economy or legal systems. ILFA suggests that experienced judges and lawyers operating in EU legal systems are more than capable of identifying threats to the integrity of our legal systems and safeguarding against the misuse or abuse of the court system for geopolitical or other aims.

Myth: “Funders are frequently the initiators of claims and may exercise control over decisions taken on behalf of claimants, and in this context, they prioritise their own financial aims over the interests of claimants. Faced with years of litigation brought by claimants with support from well-resourced funders, expensive legal costs, and reputational risk, defendants are often forced to settle even unmeritorious claims.”

Litigation funders make passive outside investments, meaning that funders do not initiate claims or control the matters in which they invest. A recipient of legal funding, and their legal counsel, maintain full control over the conduct of the case, including strategy and ultimate decision-making.

Myth: “If Europe continues to neglect proper oversight of private TPLF we risk our courts becoming profit facilitators for litigation funders, at the expense of European companies, consumers, and the integrity of our court systems.”

The reference to European companies is a curious one. Litigation funders make no distinction between EU or ‘non-EU’ claimants, basing funding awards on factual criteria such as the legal merits of a case, budget, funding required, and any other award and risks associated with the case.

This latest call from big businesses makes clear they continue to side with corporate wrongdoers, diminishing the legitimate rights of businesses and consumers to access justice and exercise their rights before the courts.

“Misleading and inaccurate claims like these appear around the world as part of a global lobbying effort to encourage unnecessary and burdensome regulation of the legal finance sector,” said Rupert Cunningham, ILFA’s newly appointed Global Director for Growth and Membership Engagement.  “Robustly challenging these persistent myths is critical to improving understanding of the sector amongst policy makers and wider industry stakeholders. That is why it is so important that international organisations like ILFA are able to respond to these claims on behalf of the sector, wherever and whenever they appear.”

By enabling the pursuit of meritorious claims, litigation funding levels the playing field and creates an equality of means between otherwise unequal parties.


[1] https://www.europeanlawinstitute.eu/fileadmin/user_upload/p_eli/Publications/ELI_Principles_Governing_the_Third_Party_Funding_of_Litigation.pdf

About the author

John Freund

John Freund

Commercial

View All

Litigation Capital Management Secures Further Covenant Waiver Extension

Litigation Capital Management has obtained another short extension of the covenant waiver on its debt facility with Northleaf Capital Partners, moving the expiry date from 13 November 2026 to 27 November 2026.

As reported by Investegate, the AIM-quoted funder disclosed the extension in a regulatory announcement released on 16 November 2026. Interest on the loan remains increased by 2.00% per annum for the duration of the extension, and no additional one-time waiver fee is payable.

The move continues a sequence of short-dated waivers the company has disclosed through the second half of 2026. Earlier extensions carried the waiver to the end of September and then to 13 November, with each announcement arriving close to the preceding deadline.

Covenant waivers give a borrower temporary relief from financial tests attached to a facility. For a litigation funder, cash flows depend on the timing of case resolutions, which cannot be scheduled with precision, so covenant headroom is closely linked to the pace at which concluded matters convert into cash.

Litigation Capital Management has not disclosed further detail on the facility or on the discussions behind the extension. The current waiver runs to 27 November 2026.

UK Campaign to Ban “No Win, No Fee” Advertising Also Seeks Funder Regulation

A new UK campaign calling for a ban on "no win, no fee" advertising has coupled that demand with a call for statutory regulation of litigation funding, placing the funding industry alongside claims advertising as a consumer protection concern.

As reported by Legal Futures, the campaign was launched by Fair Civil Justice with a film screened in Parliament. The group is led by executive director Seema Kennedy, a former Conservative MP. It is pressing three demands: a ban on the term "no win, no fee" in advertising for consumer claims by law firms and claims management companies; statutory regulation of litigation funding; and clear information on costs before a consumer agrees to pursue a claim.

Kennedy said the Civil Justice Council's June 2025 report, which recommended "light touch" regulation of the funding sector, could serve "as a blueprint." The Ministry of Justice indicated in January 2026 that it would introduce a framework along those lines.

The campaign cites Solicitors Regulation Authority research published in July 2026 finding that only 21% of consumers learned the potential costs of a claim before signing. It also points to the collapse of SSB Law, after which homeowners faced legal bills of up to £70,000. Fair Civil Justice counts the British and US Chambers of Commerce among its members, and the SSB Law Victims Group and Divorce Without Debt among supporting groups. Labour MP for Burnley Oliver Ryan is also involved, with the campaign referencing the roles of the SRA and the Legal Services Board.

The Consumer Legal Association opposed the campaign, saying it ignores regulatory failures and would restrict access to justice.

Woodsford’s David Haughan Warns Funder Regulation Could Cut Competition and Raise Pricing

A senior Woodsford executive has set out how the funder picks cases, where he sees growth, and why he is wary of statutory regulation of UK litigation funding.

In an interview published by Hogan Lovells Cadwalader, conducted by Valerie Kenyon and Olivier Swain, David Haughan, senior investment officer at Woodsford, said the firm has focused on group claims since around 2019. Its core UK work is in Competition Appeal Tribunal claims and shareholder actions under sections 90 and 90A of FSMA, alongside class actions in Australia, New Zealand, Canada and the Netherlands. Woodsford also now offers services on cases it does not fund, including bookbuilding for securities claims.

On case selection, Haughan said the firm declines quickly in unfamiliar jurisdictions or where a defendant could not realistically pay, adding that "the merits of the claim are by far the most important factor."

He cautioned that "the most likely consequence of a regulatory regime is that it would reduce competition in the litigation funding market by creating barriers to entry and regulatory risk for new, or less specialised, litigation funders," urging policymakers to weigh the benefits against "an increase in pricing."

Looking ahead, Haughan said he expects continued growth in securities litigation and "some consolidation in the market within the next five years." He added that an opt-out consumer class actions regime "would materially increase our appetite to invest in product liability and environmental claims in the UK."

On control, he said Woodsford has the right to be kept informed, but "the claimants have authority over the settlement."