Justice Charity Gets £3.7M Unclaimed Settlement Windfall After Rail Fares Case
The Competition Appeal Tribunal (CAT) has ordered that £3.7 million in unclaimed damages from a £25 million rail fare settlement be transferred to the Access to Justice Foundation (ATJF), citing what it called a “very low rate of take‑up” among eligible claimants.
An article in The Global Legal Post reports that the case involved Stagecoach South West Trains, which had been accused of abusing its dominant position by failing to make boundary fares accessible to Travelcard holders, resulting in some passengers being double-charged for parts of their journeys.
Though around 1.4 million passengers were estimated to be eligible, only about £216,500 was claimed by class members. The CAT allowed an intervention by the campaign group Fair Civil Justice (FCJ), which challenged whether the claimant law firms and funders were acting in the best interests of consumers. The tribunal noted that the take‑up was “very much short of the level predicted by the class representative.” The ATJF was praised for its ability to deploy the unclaimed funds in a way that benefits the public, including its grantees. There is still a pending determination by the tribunal on how much of the remaining settlement fund should go to claimant lawyers and the litigation funder.
This development throws into relief tensions in UK class actions between the potential scale of recoveries and the actual engagement of harmed consumers. For litigation funders and law firms, it raises fundamental questions: are cases structured and promoted in ways that reach those harmed; should unclaimed funds automatically divert to charity; and how should oversight and claims notice provisions be strengthened?
For the wider legal funding industry, this could signal pushback on low participation, increased regulatory attention, and pressure to ensure that collective actions are both meaningful and accessible to their intended beneficiaries.


