Makate Moves to Void UK Investor’s 40% Stake in “Please Call Me” Payout
Nkosana Makate, the inventor of Vodacom's "Please Call Me" service, has asked the Pretoria High Court to set aside a 2011 funding agreement that entitles UK-based investor Errol Elsdon to 40% of the multimillion-rand settlement Makate is set to receive after a 17-year dispute with the telecommunications group. The challenge places the enforceability of third-party litigation funding contracts squarely before a South African court.
As reported by Sowetan, Makate entered into an arrangement under which Black Rock, a British Virgin Islands company associated with Elsdon, would fund all of his legal costs against Vodacom in exchange for a 40% share of any eventual recovery. Makate's legal team now argues that Black Rock "breached the contract from the start because it never had the money to fund the litigation," noting that the company was deregistered in 2014 after failing to file financial statements.
Makate further alleges that Elsdon and his associates made fraudulent misrepresentations about Black Rock's financial standing before the agreement was signed. Elsdon counters that his company advanced approximately R2.9 million toward Makate's legal fees before encountering cash-flow difficulties.
The case has not yet been heard. Its outcome could carry broader implications for how courts assess funder capacity, disclosure, and the proportionality of contingent returns in cross-border litigation funding agreements.







