Sony Defeats £2bn Funded PlayStation Class Action at the CAT
The Competition Appeal Tribunal has dismissed the Woodsford-funded class action against Sony in its entirety, ending a claim that once carried a headline value of up to £5bn and stood at roughly £1.97bn including interest by the time it reached trial.
As reported by Law News, the Tribunal ruled unanimously in *Alex Neill Class Representative Limited v Sony Interactive Entertainment Europe Limited and another* [2026] CAT 86, handed down Tuesday. The panel of Ben Tidswell, Lord Richardson and Derek Ridyard concluded that "the Class Representative has failed to establish that Sony has infringed competition law."
Filed in August 2022 on behalf of around 12.2 million UK PlayStation owners, the claim alleged that Sony's 30% commission on PlayStation Store sales inflated prices by roughly 20% across a class period running from August 2016 to February 2026. Following a ten-week trial between March and May 2026, the Tribunal found against the class representative on every substantive issue.
Market definition proved decisive. The Tribunal rejected the proposed PlayStation-only aftermarket, finding that physical games and rival platforms constrained Sony's pricing, and was not satisfied Sony held a dominant position on any relevant market. It also found the 30% commission was neither excessive nor unfair. The class representative had advanced no alternative market definition and accepted in closing that the claim would fail on such a finding.
The outcome contrasts sharply with the same Tribunal's conclusion in *Kent v Apple* that Apple's equivalent App Store commission was abusive. Alex Neill said she was disappointed and is weighing options including an appeal. A further hearing on costs and permission to appeal is set for the week beginning 14 December.









